Consent and Medical Treatment
Read decision scenario 8 on p. 107 and answer questions 1, 2, and 4. Would your answer to any of these questions change if the treatment gave Alice a 50% chance of surviving for another year?
Do you think Dax Cowart (see page 3) should have been allowed to die? If so, at what point and under what circumstances should he have been allowed to make that decision?
Two conflicting claims about people who are in great pain are discussed in the readings: (a) People can never fully understand (or even remember) how awful pain can be, and so those not in pain should not presume to make decisions for those who are in pain. Those in pain should be the ones to make decisions about how much they can stand. (b) People in pain are not in a good position to make serious medical decisions, because the pain clouds their ability to decide rationally. Which of these do you agree with more? Why?
Read decision scenario 8 on p. 107 and answer questions 1, 2, and 4. Would your answer to any of these questions change if the treatment gave Alice a 50% chance of surviving for another year?
Do you think Dax Cowart (see page 3) should have been allowed to die? If so, at what point and under what circumstances should he have been allowed to make that decision?
Two conflicting claims about people who are in great pain are discussed in the readings: (a) People can never fully understand (or even remember) how awful pain can be, and so those not in pain should not presume to make decisions for those who are in pain. Those in pain should be the ones to make decisions about how much they can stand. (b) People in pain are not in a good position to make serious medical decisions, because the pain clouds their ability to decide rationally. Which of these do you agree with more? Why?
Need a Professional Writer to Work on this Paper and Give you a 100 % Original Paper?
No comments:
Post a Comment